Product Details

• Amazon Sales Rank: #44471 in Books
• Published on: 2007-01-28
• Binding: Mass Market Paperback
• 188 pages

Synopsis
Rene Descartes was a central figure in the scientific revolution of the seventeenth century. In his Discourse on Method he outlined the contrast between mathematics and experimental sciences, and the extent to which each one can achieve certainty. Drawing on his own work in geometry, optics, astronomy and physiology, Descartes developed the hypothetical method that characterizes modern science, and this soon came to replace the traditional techniques derived from Aristotle. Many of Descartes' most radical ideas such as the disparity between our perceptions and the realities that cause them have been highly influential in the development of modern philosophy.

Customer Reviews

Discourse on Method and the Meditations
This may not have been made clear before but this book actually contains two seperate books as mentioned in the title.

'Discourse on method' is the book in which Descartes first utters the maxim which is generally acknowledged to be the foundation of all modern philosophy: "I think therefore I am". This first book is mainly about his realisation that all perceived truths are to be taken with a grain of salt and provides a step by step method on how to live your intellectual life so as to avoid mistruths which the subjective view of things can provide. It is fairly interesting in some parts but largely boring in others. It is worth a read but nothing compared to 'The meditations'.

'The Meditations' is Descartes' masterpiece, it is also his most famous. It is in this book that he gives his account of the infamous, all powerful deceptive demon which tricks us to the point that we cannot trust any information presented to us. Descartes also provides his version of the ontological argument for God which is easily understandable compared to other more confusing versions. However, you would be mistaken in thinking that this book is limited in the ideas it has to offer. The arguments that Descartes puts forward is numerous but they are all extremely interesting and anyone would benefit from reading them. I highly recommend this book.

As for any further reading I would suggest Locke's "Essay Concerning Human Understanding", something by Hume or if you are up to the challenge then "Ethics" by Spinoza which builds on what Descartes says and confronts the problem of the interaction between mind and body if they are to be thought of as separate entities.

Good pictures shame about the content
I found this book to be in parts hilarious. Some of the cutting humour had me in stitches. On the whole though I was mostly unimpressed as it failed to sustain this level of wit throughout the book.

'The Meditations' leave us with much to contemplate
With such works as 'The Republic' (Plato), the 'Metaphysics' (Aristotle), 'A Treatise of Human Nature' (David Hume) and the 'Critique of Pure Reason' (Immanuel Kant), Descartes' 'Meditations' is one of the seminal achievements in Western philosophical thought. Composed over six days in 1641, they consider, among other things, the existence of the self, the existence of God and the basis of human belief. Rene Descartes (1596-1650) has been dubbed the 'Father of Modern Philosophy', and the 'Discourse On Method' and the 'Meditations'- among his most studied texts- clearly demonstrate why. Descartes, writing in the first person, offers us a telling insight into his composition of the 'Meditations', and gives us clues as to what feelings and emotions he experienced in writing them. John Locke (1632-1704), the father of the British Empiricist movement (the belief that all knowledge is based on experience) spoke in 'An Essay Concerning Human Understanding' (1690) of how new concepts are often ignored for that very reason- that they are new, and often defy convention. Yet Descartes' 'Meditations'- riddled not with new ideas but with new ways of looking at familiar ideas- have stood the test of time. They are six thoughtful, beautifully-written essays which leave us with much to contemplate through their remarkable originality. F.E. Sutcliffe offers a lucid translation that amplifies Descartes' genius, through his clear presentation of the Frenchman's ideas and concerns.