Listmania!
How to be melancholy...without getting depressed
Somebody OutsideSomebody Outside by Anna Ternheim
Buy new: £12.49
My favourite master of melancholy music. Let the sensitive serenity of this acoustic gem dispel blackening clouds. Standouts: "I’ll follow you tonight", "I say no", "Shoreline"
A Girl Called EddyA Girl Called Eddy by Girl Called Eddy
Buy new: £7.98 / Used from: £4.05
Erin Moran (aka Eddy) brilliantly captures ethereal melancholy and the langour of loneliness in her emotionally honest debut album. Best songs: “Somebody Hurt You”, “Golden”, “Tears all over town”
The GreatestThe Greatest by Cat Power
Buy used from: £2.97
The gorgeous, smoky voice of Chan Marshall (aka Cat Power) sings of hard-won emotional insights and experiences in drowsy, world-weary songs. Greatest: "Lived in bars", "Where is my love"
Out of SeasonOut of Season by Beth Gibbons & Rustin' Man
Buy new: £4.97 / Used from: £2.19
A bewitching masterpiece from the Portishead singer, with its enchanting, whistling wind opening: “God knows how I adore life...". Highlights: "Resolve", "Mysteries"
Five Leaves LeftFive Leaves Left by Nick Drake
Buy new: £4.55 / Used from: £3.00
Okay, I admit that he did possibly take his own life at a frighteningly young age, but his delicate-as-cotton-wool voice still exudes a fragility and wisdom that is uplifting. Best: "Time has told me"
Over Fly OverOver Fly Over by Kathryn Williams
Buy new: £9.48 / Used from: £4.50
Melancholy you could lick like Haagen Dazs! Brilliantly unfussy singing and story-telling from this British singer-songwriter. Standouts: "Beachy head", "Old low light #2"
Trailer ParkTrailer Park by Beth Orton
Buy new: £4.56 / Used from: £1.00
Although having recently disappeared into MOR territory, the raw, reedy singing on her earlier albums convey a diffuse sense of melancholy, without ever drifting into the depressing. Tip: "I wish..."
The Letting GoThe Letting Go by Bonnie 'Prince' Billy
Buy new: £9.98 / Used from: £7.98
The title is taken from an Emily Dickinson poem, herself a master of poetic melancholy: “First—Chill—then Stupor—then the letting go”. Try: "Cursed sleep", "Love comes to me"
Time (The Revelator)Time (The Revelator) by Gillian Welch
Buy new: £7.98 / Used from: £4.90
Glory in the deeply-felt wisdom of the title track of this country-folk album – “who could know if I'm a traitor? / Time’s a revelator --”
No More Shall We PartNo More Shall We Part by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
Buy new: £4.98 / Used from: £3.20
Nobody does highly-literate romanticism better than Nick Cave. Some of these tracks could stand alone as poetry. Favourite track: "Love Letter"
Both Sides NowBoth Sides Now by Joni Mitchell
Buy new: £7.45 / Used from: £5.56
Mitchell charts the arc of a modern romantic relationship, accompanied by full orchestra. It’s her own two tracks that do the deepest and most exquisite soul-bearing: "A Case of You", "Both Sides Now"