Product Description

"The Madness of Colonel Warburton/The Star of the Adelphi/The Saviour of Cripplegate Square/The Singular Inheritance of Miss Gloria Watson" In the fifty-six short stories and four novels, Arthur Conan Doyle wrote about his great detective, there are many passing references to successful cases that are never actually written about. These four stories, written by the main dramatist on the complete BBC Radio 4 Sherlock Holmes canon, imaginatively flesh out the cases behind those references to wonderful effect. As in the complete dramatised canon, Clive Merrison plays the great sleuth with the role of Doctor Watson played by Andrew Sachs. Cast includes Tom Baker, Eleanor Bron, Jane Asher, Tim West, Toyah Willcox. "A joy from beginning to end ...ingenious extensions of the Conan Doyle originals." - Daily Telegraph.

Product Details

• Amazon Sales Rank: #134705 in Books
• Published on: 2005-07-18
• Released on: 2005-07-18
• Format: Audiobook
• Original language: English
• Number of items: 1
• Binding: Audio CD

Customer Reviews

Sit back, close your eyes, and drift off............
Most Sherlockians, or even Holmsians, can remember whether and how old they were when they first heard those tow immortal words: Sherlcok Holmes. And every since the canon has been read and re-read, there have been many pretenders to Doyle's art of storytelling. This CD set travels well and fills the void nicely. This CD release is very welcome, and, considering it was released after Volume 2, long overdue.

Even though Michael Williams is no longer with us Andrew Sachs steps in admirably. In a way, he brings a new dimenson to the character and allows the pastiches to breathe........

Buy it. Savour it. Cherish with the others (BBC included). They deserve it.

So now, only two episodes left in the BBC's Further Adventures Vault. Come on now,.......

Bert Coules made a decent effort
Langrange once said that Newton was lucky, for there was a universe for him to discover. Perhaps everyone after Doyle writing a Doyle-styled story is to suffer the same fate as Langrange in the Newtonian universe -- the Holmesian detective universe is already discovered by Doyle, and not matter how hard you try, you are in his sky.

Bearing this thought in my mind, I give this CD 4 stars. The 1 star difference between the original Doyle stories and these new Bert Coules stories is perhaps a reflection of the quality of the stories. Coules is a very talented story teller. His dramatization of the original Doyle series is the best one I have ever owned. Yet when comparing his story with that of Doyle, there is a bit of rush, a bit lack of the gripping sense that you can usually feel in the Doyle stories. Somehow, this new English series has that popular American tint in it. This is not only reflected in the Hollywood words utter inadvertently from the new Holmes' mouth (like "a dark story at a dark night" -- does not it remind you of Disney's Aladdin? And that happens to be at "the wrong place at a wrong time" -- was not it the phrase used by MacArthur in describing the Korean War?), but also in the crime logic embedded in the stories. Doyle's criminals are more calculated rationals, Coules' criminals have that common American madness in them. Second story -- killing in a rage -- Third story -- killing as a god, and the fourth story -- stealing to prove oneself, these plots are all too familiar to a Hollywood horror movie watcher. I do not know if it makes that much sense to a Victorian man, but at least Doyle has little effort devoted to people like Jack the Ripper. (Yes, Jack the Ripper is an English too,but a mad one. He is in no way comparable to the most lamented professor Moriarty.)

Still, I enjoyed tremendously in listening to it. Sometimes, I think the reason why I bought this CD sets is that I, like those at Doyle's time, do not want to see Holmes perish either. Clive Merrison is as good as before, though traveling in a "new world". But I ran into some difficulty in adjusting to the new Watson. To me, the sound of Michael Williams gives the definition of a perfect Watson, and this one deviate much from him.

All in all, I want to thank Bert Coules in making a decent effort. A non-perfect new Holmes story told by an English is still ten times better than those "woman in green" stuffs!

Buy the real thing
Perhaps it's because these cases are not Canonical but only mentioned in passing, or perhaps it's because I have never been sold on Clive Merrison's Sherlock Holmes; but I found these cases less than interesting. Andrew Sachs, however, is so inspired as Watson (who'd have thought it -- it's much better than his Father Brown) one almost wishes they'd cast him in this role long ago. It's always intriguing to see (or, in this case, hear) how pastiches tie up loose ends in the Canon.

These are generally weak stories. "The Madness of Colonel Warburton" (with Timothy West) has a genuinely unexpected twist, but a conventional ending. My attention wandered during "The Star of the Adelphi." "The Singular Inheritance of Miss Gloria Watson" (with Roy Hudd) builds well, while "The Saviour of Cripplegate Square" (with Tom Baker) is a nasty tale of baby-farming and the misguided sympathies of those who try to play God and try to rationalize evil as good. If you want to hear about baby farming, listen to "Pinafore."

Curiously, Andrew Sachs alone almost made me give this collection four stars. I'm a connoisseur of Watsons and he's very good; but in most of the cases he isn't given enough to do. We need a "Hound of the Baskervilles"-esque case for him.