Listmania!
The Bluffer's Guide to Batman
Batman: v. 1: ChroniclesBatman: v. 1: Chronicles by Bill Finger
The original stories by Kane and Finger from 1939. Worth reading to see how nasty the original Batman really was. Yes he killed people! And after just 12 stories solo he got a sidekick, Robin.
Batman Archives Vol. 5Batman Archives Vol. 5 by Bill Finger
Buy new: £29.83 / Used from: £19.75
But it was by losing the darker aspects and becoming a child’s hero that Batman became famous. Tame maybe, but this is the first classic era, it established the mythos, and Dick Sprang’s art is a joy.
Batman in the SixtiesBatman in the Sixties by Bob Kane
Buy used from: £7.99
Sadly, by then late sixties Batman had almost become a jokey cartoon like Peanuts or Calvin and Hobbes.
Batman Illustrated - Vol 02 (Batman (DC Comics Hardcover))Batman Illustrated - Vol 02 (Batman (DC Comics Hardcover)) by Dennis O'Neil
Buy new: £22.79 / Used from: £20.48
Ta da! The second classic era! Adams transforms Batman into a nocturnal demon, while writer Denny O’Neill turns him into a DETECTIVE. This is when Batman really comes together as a viable superhero.
Batman: Dark Knight ReturnsBatman: Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller
Buy new: £6.93 / Used from: £4.75
And this is the third classic era – or version. In the mid 80s Miller revolutionized Batman and comics in general by asking “what if this guy was real” and writing for - shock! - adults.
Batman: Year OneBatman: Year One by Frank Miller
Buy used from: £3.49
Next up, Miller shows us Batman’s first year on the job as if to say, “forget the last 50 years, Batman starts here afresh”. And he did – every writer since has used Year One as their reference point.
Batman: Killing JokeBatman: Killing Joke by Alan Moore
Buy used from: £5.39
Again from the mid-eighties, Moore used Millers “real world”, adult approach, but focusing on the Joker.
Batman: Arkham Asylum Anniversary EditionBatman: Arkham Asylum Anniversary Edition by Grant Morrison
Buy new: £6.56 / Used from: £5.57
And to seal the change, Arkham Asylum was not a 10cent comic but a beautifully painted $20 adults only “graphic novel” depicting Batman himself as dangerously insane. Holy shifting demographic!
Batman: Death in the FamilyBatman: Death in the Family by Jim Starlin
Buy used from: £2.99
Ironically censorship meant the actual Batman comic couldn’t deliver material as dark as the Miller stories, so DC split Batman in two: the regular comic was more "superheroic" with epic sagas . . .
Batman: Knightfall / Broken Bat (Batman (DC Comics Paperback))Batman: Knightfall / Broken Bat (Batman (DC Comics Paperback)) by Doug Moench
Buy used from: £10.26
. . . like the death of Robin in the late 80’s, and the key early 90s epic, Knightfall, where Batman is defeated and retires, leaving a new ultra-violent Spawn-like Batman to take over . . .
Batman: No Man's LandBatman: No Man's Land by Bob Gale
Buy used from: £5.48
. . . the huge late 90s saga Cataclysm/No-Mans-Land, where Gotham is destroyed by an earthquake and is quarantined, leaving Bats (and his new team of sidekicks) to establish martial law . . .
Bruce Wayne, Fugitive: 1 (Batman (DC Comics Paperback))Bruce Wayne, Fugitive: 1 (Batman (DC Comics Paperback)) by Devin K. Grayson
Buy used from: £5.42
. . . and finally then the New Gotham arc: the city is rebuilt, gangsters replace “freak” criminals, Gordon retires, and Bruce Wayne is framed for murder.
Batman Gothic (Batman (DC Comics Paperback))Batman Gothic (Batman (DC Comics Paperback)) by Grant Morrison
Buy used from: £7.99
Meanwhile for fans of the darker Frank Miller-style Batman, DC launched a second “unrated” line in the late 80s, picking up from Year One and showing his early years as a solo vigilante . . .
Batman: PreyBatman: Prey by Doug Moench
Buy used from: £12.00
. . . notable stories, being Gothic (above) and Prey, where he tries to win Gordon’s trust, builds a Batmobile and meets his first costumed supervillain – Catwoman . . .
Batman: Long HalloweenBatman: Long Halloween by Jeph Loeb
Buy new: £8.46 / Used from: £7.25
. . . and the two great epics from Loeb and Sale: The Long Halloween, which retcons the origins of Two-Face and the rise of the "freaks", and Dark Victory, which retcons the origins of Robin.
Batman: Gotham by GaslightBatman: Gotham by Gaslight by Brian Augustyn
Buy used from: £11.10
If that wasn’t confusing enough, DC launched a range of graphic novels/mini-series that sat OUTSIDE continuity - an excuse for writers/artists to “do their thang”, like Mignola's Victorian Batman . .
Batman: War on CrimeBatman: War on Crime by Paul Dini
Buy used from: £22.85
. . . Alex Ross's poetic "day-in-the-life", featuring beautiful photo-realistic painted art . . .
Batman: Child of DreamsBatman: Child of Dreams by Kia Asamiya
Buy used from: £5.00
. . . Kia Asamiya’s stunning Manga take on Batman . . .
Batman and Dracula: Red RainBatman and Dracula: Red Rain by Doug Moench
Buy used from: £26.95
. . . and the infamous Bloodstorm trilogy where Batman becomes a vampire, literally a bat. Maaaaan!
Batman: HushBatman: Hush by Jeph Loeb
Buy used from: £28.00
So there you go, three types of Batman book out there and those are the landmarks. What of Batman in the 21st century? First up is Hush, DAZZLING art and every ally, villain and fan boy scenario.
Batman: Broken CityBatman: Broken City by Brian Azzarello
Second up is Broken City, the polar opposite, low on gadgets, sidekicks and supervillains, with a hardboiled Batman that makes even Miller’s version look soft – imagine Batman in Sin City. Smashing!
Batman: War Games Act 1Batman: War Games Act 1 by Anderson Gabrych
Buy used from: £19.99
The key epic of the recent times. Since No-Mans-Land Batman is increasingly insular, mean and fascist – a high-tech general, his sidekicks his troops, the city HIS domain. Wargames marks his hubris.
Batman: Under the HoodBatman: Under the Hood by Judd Winick
Buy new: £4.16 / Used from: £10.91
The sequel. To be honest, apart from Miller and Moore, most of these books are great kids entertainment, but with War Games and Under The Hood the writing is as good as say Lost or CSI.
Batman: Face the FaceBatman: Face the Face by James Robinson
Buy used from: £21.90
A new era begins, back to basics: just Batman, Robin, a returned Gordon, and the key supervillains. Old school superheroics and a warmer, humbler Batman.
Batman & SonBatman & Son by Grant Morrison
Buy used from: £15.00
I said new era but . . . here it begins: the famous Batman RIP storyline. After seventy years this is the end of Bruce Wayne as Batman.