Listmania!
Pink Floyd studio albums from best to worst
The Final CutThe Final Cut by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.98 / Used from: £3.81
That's the one where Roger Waters finally took absolute control and came up with a surprising masterpiece. Good work!
Wish You Were HereWish You Were Here by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £6.98 / Used from: £4.74
No undeniable embarrassments on here, which I can't really say for the better-known "Dark Side of the Moon".
MeddleMeddle by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.98 / Used from: £4.00
"Seamus" IS a bit of an embarrassment, but at 2:17 it can be easily overlooked on any prog rock album. And "Echoes" (23:31!) is arguably the best song ever written by someone who wasn't a Beatle.
The Dark Side of the MoonThe Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £6.98 / Used from: £4.98
Back in 1973, the fact that a record sold well was an indication of quality instead of a lack of it. If "On the Run" spoils things a little, again it's only 3:31 out of 42:54. So there.
AnimalsAnimals by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £6.88 / Used from: £5.63
A little unnecessary padding on this one, this is still a revelation to anyone who cares about the quality of what they listen to.
The Piper at the Gates of DawnThe Piper at the Gates of Dawn by Pink Floyd
Buy used from: £3.29
Gee, it's hard to fit this in on a Pink Floyd list, since it doesn't sound like anything else in their entire back catalogue. This ranking should therefore be taken with a pinch of salt.
The WallThe Wall by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £8.98 / Used from: £6.99
This compares very well with the Beatles' so-called white album. So again, it's hard for me to judge. But I do know I prefer the more direct "Final Cut" (well, it IS at the top of my list).
The Division BellThe Division Bell by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.98 / Used from: £2.99
You know, I can't help noticing that the Gilmour-led Floyd is just beginning to be seen in a more favourable light. And that's a good thing in my book.
A Momentary Lapse of Reason [Original Recording Remastered]A Momentary Lapse of Reason [Original Recording Remastered] by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.98 / Used from: £2.98
See above on this one. Possibly the most underrated rock record ever.
Atom Heart MotherAtom Heart Mother by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.88 / Used from: £3.00
Now here's a tough listen! But it's worth it.
Obscured by CloudsObscured by Clouds by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.98 / Used from: £3.98
Soundtracks are inherently dangerous, but this is one of the better one's I've heard. "Childhood's End" in particular is a fantastic song, but the instrumentals drag this album down a peg or two.
A Saucerful of SecretsA Saucerful of Secrets by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.88 / Used from: £3.80
This one feels like a soundtrack in parts, especially the almost-12-minute title track with its apocalyptic battle noise. That doesn't make for an easy listen.
MoreMore by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £4.98 / Used from: £4.00
This one IS a soundtrack, and it shows. But there are some underrated gems to be found, most notably the almost folky "Cymbaline".
UmmagummaUmmagumma by Pink Floyd
Buy new: £8.98 / Used from: £7.00
Worst Pink Floyd album ever. Sorry, but half a double-LP of failed studio experiments isn't my cup of tea. Even if I've drawn my alias from one of the live album tracks, as you may have realized.